Almost there! :)
In Chrome and IE9, it shows you still have the main image (above the menu bar) pointing to the local site:
http://localhost:8888/MolinaroAppraisalServices/wp-content/uploads/2013/08/cropped-bowl2.png
It looks as though it is part of the theme so that's why it didn't get changed with that plugin.
Find where that is located and change the localhost:8888 to www.molinaroappraisalservices.com